|
| |
| Resume - What are the issues? |
| JOBSAtAnytime+ |
View |
|
|
naukri.com |
| Attributes that are important for matching are entirely enumerated using many hierarchical lists. These lists support the concept of groups and are exhaustive and dynamic (chances are that you will find all values/objects/names of interest but in case if they are not found - you are allowed to add new entries, so you do not compromise on the information you wish to provide in your profile). Errors in matching are eliminated as you just select from the same list that work providers refer to! |
|
|
| Scantily enumerated and often typed; flat
lists which are very short and static (i.e.
you are forced to compromise by choosing a
substitute for a missing attribute value, thus compromising on accuracy of your profile).
Concept of groups is missing. |
| |
|
|
|
| |
| Qualifications & Credits Attributes |
| JOBSAtAnytime+ |
View |
|
|
naukri.com |
You can enter your qualifications and credits details for each of the following:
Degree
Diploma
Test-Education
Certificate-Academic
Certificate-Non Academic
Membership - Academic/Professional
Honour / Award by Society
License
Patent
Copyright
Publication.
JAA has practically all universities and colleges in the English speaking world.
|
|
|
Limited choices only
for:
Degrees
Diploma
Certificate only for SSC
& HSC
Naukri has limited names of colleges in India.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| |
| Experience & Achievements Attributes Others |
| JOBSAtAnytime+ |
View |
|
|
naukri.com |
Experience gained by different ways can be input by you..
Working in an organisation
Self employment
Self study/Hobby
Project work
Site Visit - study tour
Attending Conference/Seminar
Functional areas and concentrations are defined as combinations between functions (verbs) and knowledge domains (nouns); these number in hundreds of thousands!
| |
|
| Functions performed |
- several 00's |
| Knowledge domains engaged |
- tens of 000's |
| Objects and tools used |
- several 000's |
| Occupation titles |
- few 000's |
| Lines of Business |
- few 000's |
|
|
|
"Experience" is not
categorised. Inputs from jobs held in Organisations
only.
Functional areas are provided < 00' nos..
| |
|
| Objects/tools |
- text form and type |
| Occupation titles |
- options given <0' nos. |
| Lines of business |
- options given < 00'nos. |
|
| |
|
|
top |
|
|
| |
| Work Interest Areas - What are the issues? |
| JOBSAtAnytime+ |
View |
|
|
naukri.com |
| You are allowed to express your interests by enumerating functions and knowledge domains with corresponding time concentrations desired; you can enforce these with varying levels of tolerance (strictness). This helps in getting matched position of your interest as well. JAA has other preference criteria like Locations, Time slots, Remuneration etc. |
|
|
Naukri has preference criteria like Location, Full Time, Part Time; Does not have Time slots, Remuneration requirements. |
| |
|
|
top |
|
|
| |
| Queries: Managing Responses - What are the issues? |
| JOBSAtAnytime+ |
View Query |
View Query Result |
|
|
naukri.com |
| You are allowed to set up multiple filters (set of conditions) to block unwanted responses so that even as a passive user (one who has just created the resume and is not actively searching for a job) you get relevant matches. You can make queries with a host of filters and ranking criteria with weightages (signifying importance) and scores for different values (signifying preferences). All criteria are not displayed in your resume. You get a shortlist ranked by merit. You preserve your privacy and negotiation advantage. |
|
|
|
There is NO query submission and response
facility, however, there is online search facility
only. This has limited search parameters:
location, experience period in years, industry,
job category and functional areas.
Work
Seeker can post an agent and Naukri sends a job by
email. |
| |
|
| |
|
|
top |
|
|
| |
| Value Added Services - What are the issues? |
| JOBSAtAnytime+ |
View |
|
|
naukri.com |
| You can browse through classified ads of the important work positions advertised in the national press and those posted directly by the work provider. You may choose to apply to any of them - your resume may be sent with a covering letter as is or customised through email, post or courier; this saves you the hassle of printing or mailing! You can attach photos or other objects (audio/video clips). You can keep track of your applications and can follow-up with letters. |
|
|
There is no such
facility. |
| |
|
|
top |
|
|
| |
| Scanning Service - What are the issues? |
| JOBSAtAnytime+ |
|
|
naukri.com |
| You can zip through thousands of advertisements posted directly and also those entered from publications after indexing. You can browse through this data base of classified ads, within preset limits, by applying smart index filters. |
|
|
You can browse through classified
ads. with options of date, position and location. |
| |
|
|
top |
|
|
| |
| Confidentiality and data shareability - What are the issues? |
| JOBSAtAnytime+ |
|
|
naukri.com |
| You can control the confidentiality and data shareability. Choose your own comfort level. Your data cannot be browsed by anyone. It is sent by email / post to only those who match your filter criteria and only the permitted data is disclosed. You can even prohibit sharing your data and specify one way flow of data to you. |
|
|
The confidentiality option exist. You can define the names of the companies that
you would not like to send your resume to. You can hide
your/current company's name/tele nos. |
| |
|
|
top |
|
|
| |
| Cost-efficiency - What are the issues? |
| JOBSAtAnytime+ |
|
|
naukri.com |
You can register and subscribe for a very low cost. Standard resume is crisp and well structured - it is based on your own inputs so it does not run the risk of appearing phony.
Query charges are debited only if responses matching your criteria are generated by the system. In passive mode, the responses received by you are free (and these are sent only after honouring your profile filters.)
Long-term subscriptions come with hefty discounts. |
|
|
Registration is free. The
profile development charges are Rs.1250. To display
your resume for one year charges are Rs.750. Blasting
resumes to 1000 domestic placement consultants costs
Rs.850. Receiving of job alerts costs Rs. 750. |
| |
|
|
top |
|
|
| |
| Points of Comparison - Issues & Features |
| |
| Resume |
| Precision in profiling human expertise by accurate and complete depiction of one's |
| |
|
| a) |
qualifications & credits |
| b) |
experience & achievements/awards |
| |
|
| Typing these attributes invariably leads to ambiguities and errors that defeat automated matching processes. Therefore, these "values/objects/names" should ideally be selected from predefined lists. Automated processes do not forgive mistakes. Even manual evaluations get a big boost with crisp definitions and tabular representation of enumerated data instead of long winding sentences. Today degrees alone do not convey the different knowledge domains taught/studied. People perform diverse functions that are difficult to guess from their designations (job titles). So compilation of exhaustive AND dynamic attribute lists is critical for computer assisted matching services. |
|
| back |
|
| |
| Work Interest Areas |
| By extrapolating one's qualification or experience it is not proper to attempt matching, for e.g. a Chartered Accountant may wish to switch to a career in Information Technology or an English Teacher may wish to join a Theatre or take up Acting |
| back |
|
| |
| Queries: Managing Responses |
| A work seeker should be able to ideally specify essential conditions that must be met in a matching offer and those that are desirable. Among the latter there should be a way of indicating importance and preferences for specific properties. Real life is not black and white so there ought to be a way of ranking by merit. |
| back |
|
| |
| Value Added Services |
| Work seekers often read news papers or magazines for advertised positions and then apply directly. While making applications to certain positions, work seekers may choose to tweak their standard resume or make notes for follow-up or points discussed or to be negotiated. Applications may have to be printed and couriered or posted to specific advertisers etc. Photos of multi-media objects may have to be submitted. |
| back |
|
| |
| Scanning Service |
| Scanning advertisements of work positions - from publications can cost a lot of time and money. |
| back |
|
| |
| Confidentiality and data shareability |
| Work seekers wish to protect their identity and yet be able to match suitable work positions; they may wish to block matching with specific organisations or types of work positions |
| back |
|
| |
| Cost-efficiency |
| 1) |
Standard offering should include creation of a resume that is accurate and comprehensive. Multiple formats should be available - detailed for fresher and summary for experienced work seekers. |
| |
|
| 2) |
Cost payable by you should depend upon the success achieved, i.e. the relevant responses actually generated and |
| |
|
| 3) |
Registration fees and subscription fees for online storage that supports passive mode should be low with discounts for long-term renewals |
|
| back |
|
|
